how to write a song with no experience

how to write a song with no experience

By Daniel BrooksSongwriter on the Songive team.

Updated 8 min readGuides

You don't need chords, a rhyming dictionary, or a good singing voice. You need a few true things about one person. Write those down plainly, and the melody follows from there.

Listen to this article

A song we made for a birthday — have a listen:
Create the song

How to write a song with no experience: start with facts, not music. Write down four or five true things about the person — how they take their tea, the phrase they always say, the thing they did in 2019 that you never forgot. Those lines become the song. The tune is the last part, not the first.

What this is: writing a song with no musical experience means putting the emotional content — the details, the story, the feeling — into plain words, then letting a melody carry them. The craft you're missing (chords, meter, harmony) is the part that can be handled for you. The part only you can do is knowing the person.

We say this to people every week. Someone lands on our desk convinced they can't do this, because they picture the wrong job. They picture a piano and a blank staff. That's not the job. The job is remembering someone accurately, and that has nothing to do with music theory.

Do I need to know music to write a song?

No. You need to know a person. Every song we've ever made started as a short note from someone who couldn't read a note of music, and those notes were the whole reason the songs worked. The birthday one below began as three lines a daughter sent us about her mum — the garden, the terrible driving, the way she calls everyone "love." We didn't add the feeling. It was already there in the details she chose.

Musical experience helps you arrange a song. It does not help you know that your dad hums while he does the washing up, or that your best mate once drove four hours to sit with you and said nothing. Those are the load-bearing bricks. The rest is decoration you don't have to lay yourself.

The actual steps, from where you're standing

Here's what we tell people who've never written a line in their life.

Step one — collect true things, not clever ones

Don't reach for poetry. Reach for accuracy. Open your notes app and write plainly: what they always order at the pub, the nickname nobody outside the family understands, the year everything changed, the way they say goodbye on the phone. Five of those beat one grand sentence about love. Grand sentences fit anybody. A song only works when it couldn't possibly be about somebody else.

Step two — pick the one moment the song is really about

Songs drown when they try to cover a whole life. Choose a single scene. The morning of the wedding. The hospital waiting room. The kitchen at Christmas after everyone's gone to bed. When people ask us how to write a song for someone, this is the turn we push hardest — one room, one afternoon, one thing that happened. The listener feels the whole relationship through that one window.

Step three — say how you want it to feel, then let it be built

You don't arrange the music yourself. You describe the person, hand over your notes, and tell us the mood — warm and slow, or daft and upbeat, or quiet like the last song at a wake. A first version comes back in about two minutes so you can hear whether it sounds like them. If a verse lands wrong, you say so, and it changes. No sheet music ever touches your hands.

What we notice actually makes these land

The songs that make people cry are almost never the ones with the most impressive words. They're the ones with the most specific ones. "You always leave the porch light on for me" beats "you were always there for me" every single time, and the person who wrote the first line swore up and down they weren't creative.

The other pattern: people underestimate the plain stuff. A brief that just says "she loves her allotment, she raised three of us on a nurse's wage, she never once let us see her tired" is a better starting point than a page of adjectives. Facts carry weight. Adjectives float off.

How this compares to the other ways in

If you can't write music, you've basically got a handful of options, and they ask very different things of you. Learning an instrument well enough to write a song is a project measured in years. Hiring a songwriter outright gives you a bespoke result but takes weeks of back-and-forth. A karaoke track or a Spotify playlist skips the writing entirely but also skips the point — it's someone else's words. Songive sits in the middle: you supply the truth, the writing and the music are handled, and the finished thing has their name in it.

Route What you need to bring Time Names the specific person
Learn an instrument Years of practice Very long Only if you also write
Hire a songwriter A brief plus patience Weeks Yes
Songive A few honest lines About two minutes Yes, their name in it
Karaoke / cover Nothing but the recipient Instant No
A playlist Taste Instant No

What to put in the notes about them

If the blank box is the scary part, fill it with these four.

  1. One phrase they actually say. Not a description of how they talk — the words themselves. "Right, who's for a brew?" or "we'll sort it in the morning." Their voice on the page pulls the whole song toward the truth.
  2. A single scene with a place in it. Not "we had good times" but "the caravan in Whitby, the rain hammering the roof, you making toast on the little grill." A place gives the song walls to stand in.
  3. The thing you've never said out loud. The reason you're doing this at all. Even one line — "I don't think I ever thanked you properly" — reshapes everything around it.
  4. The mood you want them left in. Should they laugh, or should they need a minute? Tell us plainly. "Make it a bit cheeky" and "keep it gentle, she's had a hard year" produce two completely different songs, and you're the only one who knows which is right.

That's the whole job. You bring the person; the music is not your problem. If you want to see the box you'd be filling, it's on the song creation page — and if you're still unsure how much detail matters, our note on what makes a good custom song covers it.

FAQ

Can I write a song if I have no musical experience at all?

Yes, because the part that needs experience — the melody and arrangement — is handled for you. Your job is to write down true things about the person in plain words. That's a memory exercise, not a music one, and it's the part no professional could do without you.

What do I write if I'm not good with words either?

Write facts, not phrases you think sound nice. What they always order, the year something changed, a place that matters to you both. Bald, unpoetic details make the strongest songs. You don't have to be a writer to remember someone accurately.

How long does it take to get a song back?

A first version comes back in about two minutes once you've written your notes. You listen, and if a line sounds off you ask for a change. The slow part is deciding what to say — the making itself is quick.

Do I have to choose the music style myself?

Only the mood, and only in plain words. Say whether you want it warm, cheeky, or quiet, and that's enough. You never pick chords, tempo, or key — you describe how the song should feel and it's built around that.

What if the first version doesn't sound like the person?

You say what's wrong and it's adjusted. Maybe a detail landed flat or the tone was too jolly for the occasion. Because you hear a version fast, there's room to tune it until it actually sounds like them before you send it.